“My idea of ethical behavior is treating people like you want to be treated,” Craig Newmark said. Even while facing tough choices, “if you set that as your moral compass, it’s a really good start.”
Newmark, who, in 1995, founded the online classified-ads service Craigslist before becoming a philanthropist, was the Feb. 4 guest for the “PRSA Storytellers Series: Leading With Ethics — A View From the Top,” a live webinar hosted by the PRSA Board of Ethics and Professional Standards. (Watch the webinar here.)
In 2016, he founded Craig Newmark Philanthropies, which supports organizations that advocate for trustworthy journalism, voter protection, women in technology, and military veterans and their families.
According to a Forbes article posted on the foundation’s website, it has given $170 million to such causes — including $1 million to the Global Cyber Alliance, an international computer-security nonprofit; $150,000 to the nonprofit group Women in Cybersecurity; $1 million to the nonprofit investigative journalism organization ProPublica; $250,000 to the authors’ nonprofit PEN America, to combat disinformation and online harassment; and $250,000 to the Girl Scouts, to fund cybersecurity programs.
In June 2018, Newmark’s foundation reportedly gave $20 million to the CUNY Graduate School of Journalism, which was then renamed the Craig Newmark Graduate School of Journalism. In February 2019, he donated $10 million to Columbia Journalism School, to launch a new center for journalism ethics and security.
The webinar’s moderator, Kirk Hazlett, APR, Fellow PRSA, is an adjunct professor of communication at the University of Tampa in Florida. He asked Newmark what had inspired him to support these organizations.
“My high school history teacher taught me that a trustworthy press, an ethical press, is the immune system of democracy,” Newmark said. “I saw that in 2016 the immune system of democracy didn’t work so well. And that sparked a considerable acceleration of my interest in these fields.”
On Feb. 1, a Newmark-funded report was released, called “False Accusation: The Unfounded Claim that Social Media Companies Censor Conservatives.” According to the report, “The claim of anti-conservative animus on the part of social media companies is itself a form of disinformation,” and “Republicans have promoted the idea that because most social media employees and executives are politically liberal, the platforms themselves must be hostile to conservatives.”
The report’s findings “really drew blood among the practitioners of disinformation,” Newmark said. “But for the most part, people are encouraging me to do more of it.” He’s funding “groups who are succeeding in making a change when it comes to the people who amplify disinformation.”
Newmark said he sees “major voices in the news and influential columnists who are pushing this out,” such as Margaret Sullivan at The Washington Post, Jay Rosen at New York University; and “the trio at CNN of Brian Stelter, Oliver Darcy and Donie O’Sullivan.”
If social media platforms and newspapers “can throttle back the rate of infection by information super-spreaders, that will solve a lot of the problem,” Newmark said. “I think we are doing the good things that are necessary to make for a better country.”
A member of the webinar audience asked Newmark’s advice for responding to unethical behavior from someone in your own work team. “Sooner or later, deceptive behavior does get found out,” he said. But that revelation might “hit social media and spread virally,” which is bad for the entire team. If you see unethical behavior from someone in a higher position, “Document everything in the most discreet manner possible,” he said.
When asked how public relations helps business leaders maintain an ethical mindset, Newmark said, “If you’re a group, whether for-profit or nonprofit, you need to tell people what you’re doing” through professional communications efforts. The downside “is that it exposes you to greater scrutiny.”
Greg Beaubien is a frequent contributor to PRSA publications.[Illustration credit: snopek]
To me, it sounds like Craig Newman has cracked the code of public relations. As an undergraduate public relations major, I am constantly reminded of the importance of using proper ethics in everything I write. It’s important to understand that our goal is to inform the public, while also remembering to “[treat] people like you want to be treated,” as Newman noted. Businesses and people want to be accurately represented, and it’s our job to grant them that.
Furthermore, I also agree with Newman’s teacher when she referred to a trustworthy press as “the immune system for democracy.” This statement reiterates the importance of transparency in every organization’s initiatives in order to avoid sharing any misleading or falsified news that may come back and put us in legal trouble.